With all this talk of Windass coming back from Hull.....

[beerbantam]

surely the man at Hull we should be looking at is Nathan Doyle - not Deano?

Fair enough Deano is a legend and would add to our squad, but Doyle could be just what we need in the middle of the park.
He's getting less of a look-in at Hull than Deano and though L2 would be well within him there's nothing like being in a promotion team to get going again.

[Jantje]

Fair enough Deano is a legend

No hes not, only in his ego addled mind:rolleyes::rolleyes:

[beerbantam]

No hes not,

I feel a panto style thread coming on......Oh yes he is!!;):D

[Lofty]

I feel a panto style thread coming on......Oh yes he is!!;):D

Oh no he isn't!! Great goal scorer yes, legend NO!! tup:

[Yeadon Bantam]

Whats thornes record for us like against deanos?

[Jantje]

I feel a panto style thread coming on......Oh yes he is!!;):D

Agree about Nathan Doyle thoughtup:tup:

[Lofty]

Whats thornes record for us like against deanos?

Peter Thorne - Played 42 Goals 23 (Goal every 1.83 games).

Dean Windass - Played 216 Goals 76 (Goal every 2.84 games).

Thorne's looking good although Deano was at a higher level.

[BaselBantam]

I've said it before, but,

:sing: Nathan Doyle. He's been gone too long.... :sing:

[Northern]

Peter Thorne - Played 42 Goals 23 (Goal every 1.83 games).

Dean Windass - Played 216 Goals 76 (Goal every 2.84 games).

Thorne's looking good although Deano was at a higher level.

I'm pretty sure Windass has played more games than that and scored more goals, I think he scored about 85 goals for us!

Where's BOTO when you need him? :D

[beerbantam]

Peter Thorne - Played 42 Goals 23 (Goal every 1.83 games).

Dean Windass - Played 216 Goals 76 (Goal every 2.84 games).

Thorne's looking good although Deano was at a higher level.

Deano's got 88 for us by my reckoning - i might be wrong though...

99-00 City top score with 10 goals
00-01 City top scorer with 10 goals
01-02 8 goals
04-05 top scorer with 28
05-06 top scorer with 20
06-07 top scorer with 12

[Spoonhead]

Also, one of the seasons in the Prem, he was top scorer, from centre midfield , and he didn't play the whole season. So the comparison is a bit warped. Both great strikers for us. I think they'd be awesome together. :cool:

[Lofty]

I'm pretty sure Windass has played more games than that and scored more goals, I think he scored about 85 goals for us!

Where's BOTO when you need him? :D

Don't blame me, blame Wiki!!! :D

They might just be FA Cup and League goals?!

Still rather have Thorne though cos he's not a ****!! tup:

[Parrot]

Does anyone know If Doyles still as good as he was when he was last here?

[Northern]

http://www.soccerbase.com/players_details.sd?playerid=8627

86 according to Soccerbase! tup:

[beerbantam]

Does anyone know If Doyles still as good as he was when he was last here?

Who knows? He still looked ****-hot towards the end of last year in the Championship for Hull!!

Personally i think he'd be a top quality signing and would slot in nicely in the holding position of Midfield!!

[Dionysus]

Deano's got 88 for us by my reckoning - i might be wrong though...

99-00 City top score with 10 goals
00-01 City top scorer with 10 goals
01-02 8 goals
04-05 top scorer with 28
05-06 top scorer with 20
06-07 top scorer with 12

If I remember correctly didn't he also get at least a couple in our promotion season?

I certainly remember him bagging one away at Bury, hisaway debut I believe

[Parrot]

If I remember correctly didn't he also get at least a couple in our promotion season?

I certainly remember him bagging one away at Bury, hisaway debut I believe

He scored both goals at Bury in a 2-0 win.

[TSSB]

I will ask Phil Brown next time i speak to him, Although i would go to hull myself and pick nathan doyle upmyself and deliver him back to Valley Paradejump:jump:jump:

[Tills]

IMO, Deano would definately add to our current team, probably replacing Bullock as the attacking midfielder and moving upfront in the event of injury to Thorne/Boulding. I also think he would provide the on field leadership which is sadly lacking at the moment.

Would I want him back though - Nah!!!!

We can still do enough to get out of this division with what we currently have on the pitch/bench.

Windass, thanks for the memories but it's time to move on.